Monday, December 20, 2010

Jane Eyre reflections

 As for the novel as a whole, there were ups and downs. I believe that as for America's perception of teenagers, they had it spot on. Jane believed her life was miserable, and in the end her prince charming came and saved her from it. Also, I like how many motifs there were. It made the book very interesting, and it especially made it much easier to analyze and annotate. This is a skill I didn't have much practice with, and I know I will be having to use it more once I get to college. As well as motifs, there was a lot that just generally happened. Her life as a young woman was very interesting, and there wasn't really a time when I was bored. As for what didn't work, I didn't like how dramatic everything was. I understand that teenagers are usually over dramatic, but I think Bronte took it a little too far. I would say that they should be less descriptive, but that was definitely an important motif. I don't necessarily think there needs to be any changes, I just think I didn't like some parts as much as others. I believe this book should be taught. It does teach some very good values, like pursuing your dreams and being independent, and it's also good to read a novel from a very different time period. As for last thoughts, I believe the St. John thing went wayyy too far. Also, way too many coincidences!

1 comment:

  1. I agree with most of this, but especially the bit about coincidences. There really should be some kind of limit to how much an author can stretch it like that, and I suppose there really is a limit. It may not be an imposed limit, but there is only so much a person can take before they just say, "Enough!" Personally, I would have liked it if there wasn't the whole bit about gaining an entire fortune for herself. I understand that it's about being independent as opposed to having to rely on Mr. Rochester for everything, but at the same time, it's already made perfectly clear to the reader that if anything Mr. Rochester would need her more than she needs him if that were the case. But I digress.

    ReplyDelete